Moment that mattered: Joe Biden quits the US presidential race
In issue 56 we spoke to historian and political analyst Professor Allan Lichtman about Joe Biden's decision to withdraw from the 2024 US presidential election

WASHINGTON, DC - JULY 1: U.S. President Joe Biden arrives for a news conference following the Supreme Court's ruling on charges against former President Donald Trump that he sought to subvert the 2020 election, at the White House on July 1, 2024 in Washington, DC. The highest court ruled 6-3 that presidents have some level of immunity from prosecution when operating within their "constitutional authority," but do not have absolute immunity. (Photo by Andrew Harnik/Getty Images)
21st July 2024 (Taken from: #56)
When Joe Biden announced he was quitting his presidential re-election campaign following pressure from within his party, Professor Allan Lichtman was furious. “I’ve summarised US politics in one sentence. Republicans have no principles, Democrats have no spine,” says Lichtman, a historian at American University in Washington DC. “This was the spineless Democrats at their worst and, inevitably, that tainted any [subsequent] nominee.”
After Biden stepped down, Lichtman gave a series of caustic TV interviews, in which he damned the Democrats for engaging in a “foolish, self-destructive escapade” that could lose them the election. And Lichtman’s predictions held weight. He was frequently referred to as the ‘Nostradamus’ of presidential elections having correctly predicted nine of the previous ten results. His one failure was the 2000 election between Al Gore and George W Bush, controversially decided by a few hundred hanging chads [incomplete ballot papers] in Florida. Gore won the popular vote and Lichtman believes that he would have also won the electoral college if the Florida votes had been counted correctly.
To formulate his predictions he uses a system he developed in the early 1980s with Russian seismologist and mathematical geophysicist Vladimir Keilis-Borok; the ‘13 Keys to the White House’. Each key is a true or false response to a statement such as “The incumbent administration is untainted by major scandal” and “The economy is not in recession during the election campaign.” If five statements or fewer are false, the incumbent will win. If six or more are false, the challenger will win. Using the 13 Keys, Lichtman had correctly predicted Trump’s 2016 victory, which was missed by most mainstream polling.
The clamour to replace Biden at the top of the Democratic party ticket followed his disastrous televised debate performance against Trump on 27th June. Biden appeared lost and forgetful, at times losing his train of thought. Pictures of him staring into the middle distance, wide-eyed and open mouthed, became viral memes across social media. Biden slipped six points behind Trump in the polls, giving the Republican a seemingly unassailable lead. Another significant blow for Biden’s presidential campaign came from an unusual source: George Clooney, one of the Democrats’ biggest donors and fundraisers in Hollywood. On 10th July he wrote an op-ed in the New York Times urging Biden to stand down, suggesting that he wasn’t the man he once was.
US politics in one sentence. Republicans have no principles, Democrats have no spine” — Allan Lichtman
Although he hadn’t made his prediction for the 2024 presidential election at that stage, Lichtman believed privately that Biden was still ahead on his 13 Keys system, and that getting rid of Biden threw away one of the Democrats’ biggest advantages: incumbency. “Did I feel it [Biden’s debate performance] was a fatal problem that required trashing Joe Biden and pushing him out? Absolutely not,” says Lichtman. “I’m not a doctor, but Trump has exhibited at least as many signs of diminishment. A lot of what he says is pure gibberish. It makes no sense. He talks about the ‘late, great Hannibal Lecter’. He forgets what city he’s in. He doesn’t know the name of his doctor. He calls Elon Musk ‘Leon’. He mistakes Nikki Haley and Nancy Pelosi. And do the Republicans care? Not one whit, so long as they can use him to seize and hold power, and so long as the billionaires can become even richer.”
On the same day that Biden announced he was pulling out of the race, vice president Kamala Harris announced she would run. Biden endorsed her straight away. Immediately the Democrats’ poll numbers improved, turning what was shaping up to be a crushing win for Trump and the Republicans into a race that was neck and neck. Even with the Democratic Party’s machinations, Lichtman announced on 5th September that Harris remained on course to win according to his 13 Keys. That was when the death threats started, and the men with guns showed up at his house.
“I’ve had the most scurrilous, vulgar, antisemitic, violent, threatening communications; the security of my family has twice been attempted to be breached. The police are on alert. They’ve been to our home many times. But this is just indicative of how toxic our politics has become in the era of Trump,” Lichtman says. “I’ve been swatted. I’ve been doxxed!” Swatting is a form of intimidation in which a false report is made of a violent crime in progress at someone’s house, in the knowledge that heavily armed police will arrive at their property. Doxxing is the act of maliciously posting someone’s private details online, especially their phone number and address, knowing they will be harassed. “I’m not so worried about myself. I’m now secured,” says Lichtman. “I am worried about the future of our democracy. A democracy cannot survive in an atmosphere of threats and violence.” There was a very different reaction when he predicted a Trump victory in 2016. “Those same people who have been heaping hate on me loved it when, against all the pollsters and the pundits, I predicted Donald Trump’s win,” he says.
“We have something brand new this time, Elon Musk, worth $300 billion, who controls one of the most important outlets of information, putting his thumb on the scales”
In the end, Trump beat Harris in both the electoral college and the popular vote, the first time a Republican candidate has won the popular vote since 2004. Republicans also won control of the Senate and the House of Representatives. The Supreme Court, which has a 6-3 conservative majority, also ruled earlier in 2024 that the president has broad immunity from prosecution for acts committed while in office, which gives Trump a free hand for at least two years, when midterm elections will be held.
Lichtman has had to take stock and re-evaluate his 13 Keys system, to work out what went wrong and how it can be adjusted. In hindsight, he believes that two important components made the election impossible to predict: dumping an incumbent so close to election day, which had never happened before, and the fact that America was so divided that the two sides did not have a shared belief in the truth.
“The keys can’t deal with massive, unprecedented situations, and we have never seen anything like what the Democrats did to their elected nominee, right on the eve of their convention,” he says. He also points to other causes including the actions of Elon Musk. “The keys depend upon the idea that a rational, pragmatic electorate decides whether or not the White House party has governed well enough to get four more years,” says Lichtman. Musk’s purchase of Twitter in 2022 and the flooding of social media with disinformation, he believes, helped to make it impossible for people to agree on objective facts. “You can’t have a pragmatic electorate when there is this explosion of disinformation,” he says. “We’ve always had disinformation, but nothing to this degree. It starts with Fox News and other outlets. It goes through conservative podcasters with tens of millions of listeners, and we have something brand new this time, Elon Musk, worth $300 billion, who controls one of the most important outlets of information, putting his thumb on the scales.”
Lichtman believes this is a perilous moment for US democracy. “Trump has even openly said, to maintain power, he’s willing to suspend the Constitution,” he says. “He’s now protected by the Supreme Court’s decision on immunity. If that decision had been in effect in the 1970s then Nixon would have gotten away with Watergate and our democracy may well have died 50 years ago.” Although he believes this is a dark moment, he is not ready to give up on American democracy quite yet. “I’m sceptical, but I’m also hopeful, because we’ve been through terrible times before,” he says. “The country was ripped apart by slavery. We had a bloody civil war. We endured almost 100 years of Jim Crow discrimination. I’ve always said it’s not just the evil people who wreak havoc on this world, it’s the good people who don’t do enough to stop them. Trump got 70-plus million votes, but that’s a quarter, less than a third of the adult population in this country. There’s still a lot of good people who can, and need, to stand up for our democracy.”
Slow Journalism in your inbox, plus infographics, offers and more: sign up for the free DG newsletter. Sign me up
Thanks for signing up.





