Moment that mattered: KlimaSeniorinnen win a landmark climate case at the ECHR
In issue 55 of Delayed Gratification we spoke to Elisabeth Stern of KlimaSeniorinnen, a group of Swiss pensioners who enjoyed a remarkable climate victory

Elisabeth Stern greets a fellow campaigner after the ECHR ruled that Swiss inaction on climate change violated human rights. Photo: Greenpeace
9th April 2024 (Taken from: #55)

Elisabeth Stern greets a fellow campaigner after the ECHR ruled that Swiss inaction on climate change violated human rights. Photo: Greenpeace
On 9th April a group of older Swiss women celebrated a watershed victory at the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR). The Strasbourg court ruled in favour of KlimaSeniorinnen, a group of more than 2,000 women with an average age of 73, which had argued that the Swiss government’s inadequate response to climate change had put them at greater risk of death from heatwaves.
“It was an incredible moment,” recalls Elisabeth Stern, a 77-year-old board member of the group. “Although the judgement went on and on, so it was a while before we were hugging and kissing.”
It was the first time an international court had ruled that states have a legal duty to protect their citizens from the adverse effects of climate change on health, wellbeing and quality of life. Those that failed to do so, it said, were violating fundamental human rights. The message was unambiguous – the climate crisis is a human rights crisis, and the legal precedent caused a ripple effect felt keenly in the 46 members of the Council of Europe, the states legally bound by the European Convention on Human Rights.
Greenpeace looked for women. They found the rebellious grandmothers and asked ‘Can you imagine taking on a case like this?’” — Elisabeth Stern
Stern’s own interest in climate activism can be traced to four words said to her in 1990. Back then the retired cultural anthropologist was doing field work in Zimbabwe when she met a farmer in the east of the country. “He took me out into the countryside and said, ‘Look at this dam. It used to fill with rainwater, but no more. The weather is changing.’”
“Those words, ‘the weather is changing’, were the initial spark,” Stern says. Upon her return to Switzerland she threw herself into climate research and activism. More than 20 years later, she joined KlimaSeniorinnen. The group had formed shortly after the world’s first climate liability lawsuit had been heard in The Hague, which saw a group of citizens successfully force the Dutch government to cut the country’s carbon emissions. Swiss Greenpeace wanted to do something similar, “but here you can only [take the government to court] if you are personally affected,” Stern explains. “And who were those people [affected]? Us, the older women. Several studies have shown that older women suffer the most during heatwaves… Women are clearly more affected than men.”
“So Greenpeace looked for women,” Stern continues. “They found the rebellious grandmothers, they found older women in active groups in the environmental movement. And they asked them: ‘Can you imagine taking on a case like this?’ It started with a group of 12, then when KlimaSeniorinnen was founded in 2016 [when Stern joined] there were 450 of us. Now [after a rise in membership following the 9th April judgement] we are 3,500.”
The Strasbourg victory was eight years in the making – the group only went to the ECHR after exhausting their legal avenues in Switzerland; a series of domestic courts had dismissed their case. Their success in April, Stern explains, is largely down to the Swiss government’s failure to set a national carbon budget, a tool for countries capping their emissions so that global warming can be kept below the 1.5°C mark agreed under the 2016 Paris climate accord. “Every country has to calculate how many emissions they are still allowed to let out into the air,” says Stern. “But Switzerland has been taking a piece of the CO₂ cake that is too big. People here say, ‘But our contribution to emissions worldwide is minuscule’. Yes, but we are a small country – when you look at per person per year it’s enormous. I say to them, ‘The taxes I pay are minuscule compared to the entire Swiss tax money pot, but does that mean I don’t have to pay my taxes? Of course not.’”
The women who could have spent their old age conforming to the retired stereotype, instead took on their government and won”
While the KlimaSeniorinnen celebrated the court’s ruling, they were sensitive to the fact that two other high-profile climate cases had been dismissed by the ECHR on the same day. A group of six Portuguese young people, who were trying to sue 32 European countries for climate inaction, were told their case was ineligible because they had not exhausted the legal paths available to them in their home country, while a French mayor’s case was rejected because he had moved from the coastal town he claimed was vulnerable to flooding. “The Portuguese youngsters were amazing,” Stern says. “They were crying, so we didn’t want to celebrate our victory in an insensitive way… They said to us, ‘Your win is also our win’.
In the days after the verdict the women of KlimaSeniorinnen rode a wave of success. There were many positive news reports on what sounded like a plot from a feelgood movie: the women who could have spent their old age conforming to the retired stereotype, but instead took on their government and won. But Stern had a nagging feeling that the fight wasn’t over. “I remember writing in my diary at the time, ‘Tomorrow the sharks will bite us’,” she says.
The backlash began when the Swiss People’s Party, a populist right wing group which won the country’s parliamentary elections in October 2023, described the ECHR’s ruling as a “scandal”, argued that “foreign judges” had no right to tell Switzerland what to do, and demanded that the country withdraw from the Council of Europe. Then on 12th June parliament voted to reject the ECHR’s ruling, accusing the court of “inadmissible and disproportionate judicial activism.” “I felt terribly betrayed,” says Stern of the parliamentary vote. “It was the first time that I went into mourning about this whole situation on our planet… I was devastated, and then after a few days I picked myself up.”
But then came a further blow. On 28th August, Switzerland’s federal government – which was not bound by the parliamentary vote – also rejected the ECHR ruling. It did not question the legitimacy of the court, but it criticised the “broad interpretation” of human rights that led to its verdict. It also took issue with the ECHR calling its climate policy inadequate, and cited two recent environmental acts that it said were not taken into account in Strasbourg. The politicians leading the fight against the ECHR celebrated – the Centre party’s Beat Rieder told the Neue Zürcher Zeitung paper that the government had shown that “Switzerland is a sovereign country, where parliament, people and cantons make laws – not ECHR judges.”
Opinion polls have shown that a majority of Swiss people agree with the government. Environmentalists, however, reacted with dismay to the government’s rejection of the ECHR verdict, and Stern says she “screamed at the walls” when she heard the news. “I thought I should just let it all out,” she says. “How ignorant, how stupid!” In Stern’s opinion the Swiss politicians fighting the ECHR tend to be badly informed on climate science, don’t understand the details of the judgement and are resorting to “Trumpian arguments”. She also rejects the “foreign judges” accusation. “We are a member of the European Council and the court belongs to the European Council. Ergo, those judges are our judges, it is part of our legal system.”
The Swiss government is obligated to deliver a detailed report to Strasbourg on how it is implementing the ruling by 9th October. The ruling is binding but not prescriptive – it orders Switzerland to fulfil its climate obligations but doesn’t spell out exactly how it should do so beyond measures such as setting carbon budgets. How the court will respond when Switzerland insists that it’s already fulfilling its climate obligations is not yet known. Stern worries that the stubborn Swiss response will lead to other countries rejecting ECHR verdicts, and the entire human rights system in Europe being undermined.
The elation of 9th April has since given way to frustration. Stern believes that her government has missed a golden opportunity to “learn something from the verdict”. And she says that it’s not only the older generation that has been betrayed by Swiss politicians. “Yes, we partly did it for ourselves because we suffer terribly in heatwaves… But we also did this for the future generations, for god’s sake. They will have to clean up this mess that we have left for them.”
Slow Journalism in your inbox, plus infographics, offers and more: sign up for the free DG newsletter. Sign me up
Thanks for signing up.





